Fire it up
🔥 Hot & Fast

Surf and Turf

Simple. Unforgettable.

Filet mignon and lobster tail on the Big Green Egg.

Jump to recipe ↓
Surf and Turf▶ Watch Fuzzy make it
Grill temp450–600°FDirect heat
Total time5 hrPrep 10 min · Cook 20 min
Pull at140°Finternal temp
Smoke wood🪵 Jack Daniel's BarrelVery strong smoke →

Let's cook

  1. Prep

    Take the chill off the filets and season with sea salt, pepper and olive oil. Melt the butter with the lemon juice, minced garlic and parsley. Season the lobster tails with Cajun seasoning.

  2. Fire it up

    Medium amount of natural lump charcoal with Jack Daniel's wood chips, grate directly over the flame. Bring the Egg to 500–600°F.

    🔥 500–600°F
  3. Sear the filets — side one

    Sear directly over the flame.

    🔥 500–600°F
  4. Sear the filets — side two

    Flip and sear the other side.

    🔥 500–600°F
  5. Finish the filets

    Move the filets away from the hot spot and cook to your desired internal temperature. At 140°F, let them sit 5–10 minutes before slicing.

    🔥 140°F internal
  6. Lobster — side one

    Grill the tails away from the hottest part of the flame at 450–500°F.

    🔥 450–500°F
  7. Lobster — side two

    Flip. When the meat turns beige and the shells turn bright orange and curl, pull the tails and serve immediately.

    🔥 450–500°F

Fuzzy's timeline

5 hours: 10 minutes of prep, 4½ hours to bring the filets to room temperature, and 20 minutes of cooking. Catch up on your favorite "Mom-Coms" on the DVR!

Plan ahead

Want to eat at…

Pairs with

Use the leftover butter sauce to glaze your surf and turf.

Suggested sides

  • Green beans with almonds
  • French fries (preferably Zesties)

Leftovers?

Refrigerate overnight and serve cold over a salad. Not your style? Reheat the filets in your oven at 350°F for 20 minutes.